Display massive amounts of telemetry data without losing actionable insights
Introduction
In the high-stakes world of hardtech industries telemetry data is not just a byproduct—it's a lifeline. Ensuring this data is accurate and actionable is crucial for maintaining safety, optimizing performance, and adhering to rigorous regulatory standards. However, the challenge lies in managing the massive streams of telemetry data that these systems generate. Real-time data processing becomes even more complex with the frequent and unpredictable spikes that can occur, necessitating robust solutions that can handle such demands without losing critical information.
Engineers are tasked with transforming this deluge of raw data into insights that are not only comprehensible but also timely and relevant. This is no small feat, given the computational challenges of processing and rendering vast amounts of telemetry data in real-time. The sheer volume and velocity of incoming data often exceed the processing capabilities of today’s visualization solutions, making it difficult to present meaningful insights without significant data reduction or latency.
The sheer volume and velocity of incoming data often exceed the processing capabilities of today’s visualization solutions, making it difficult to present meaningful insights without significant data reduction or latency.
The intricacies of data downsampling within observability platforms present a complex challenge. Conventional methods often fall short in preserving critical information, necessitating more sophisticated approaches. One such approach is the Largest-Triangle-Three-Buckets (LTTB) algorithm, which offers a balance between efficiency and accuracy. LTTB excels at maintaining significant patterns and transient events in the data, addressing the unique challenges of telemetry data visualization. By leveraging this technique, engineers can pave the way for more reliable and actionable insights, crucial for decision-making in hardtech environments
Data Problems
In developing Sift's platform, we encountered a critical challenge in telemetry data visualization: efficiently representing massive datasets within the constraints of standard display resolutions. While downsampling is the fundamental approach, its implementation involves complex trade-offs between data fidelity, computational efficiency, and visual accuracy. The key question became not just how to reduce data volume, but how to do so while preserving critical information and patterns essential for mission-critical applications.
The key question became not just how to reduce data volume, but how to do so while preserving critical information and patterns essential for mission-critical applications.
Downsampling large datasets involves reducing the number of data points to make data easier to process and visualize, but it can create problems maintaining the dataset’s key characteristics. Common techniques like simple averaging or random sampling can hide transient spikes or other short-lived, significant events within the data.
With standard observability tools like Grafana or Prometheus, engineers commonly employ percentile-based aggregations to capture outliers that might be obscured by simple averaging. This approach is particularly effective for datasets aggregating numerous data points from distributed systems or high-volume user interactions. However, it has limitations when applied to certain types of telemetry data, especially in real-time or near-real-time scenarios. In these cases, rare but significant anomalies—occurring perhaps only once or twice—might not be adequately represented by percentile-based methods, which typically require a larger sample size to be statistically meaningful. Furthermore, percentile calculations can be computationally expensive for high-cardinality data, potentially introducing latency in real-time monitoring scenarios.
To address these issues, Sift needed to find a downsampling technique that is efficient, accurate, and keeps significant patterns intact, capturing transient events more reliably than simple averaging or random sampling methods.
A Strategic Approach to Data Downsampling
Sift chose to use LTTB (Largest-Triangle-Three-Buckets) downsampling when displaying data on screen. LTTB is a downsampling algorithm created in 2013 by Sveinn Steinarsson, used to reduce the number of data points in a dataset while retaining the overall shape and trends of the original data. This technique is particularly useful for visualizing large datasets because it keeps the key visual characteristics intact while discarding less significant points. Here's how it works in basic steps:
- Bucket Division: The time series is divided into n-2 equal-width “buckets” along the time axis, where n is the desired number of output points. The first and last data points are preserved.
- Initialize the Result Set: Start the result with the first data point from the original dataset.
- Select Representative Points: For each bucket, choose a single point based on which one creates the largest triangle (in area) between the previous bucket’s selected point and an average of the next bucket’s points.
- Finish the Result Set: After all the points are chosen for each bucket, add the final point of the original dataset to the end of the result. The process is complete.
LTTB is commonly used for plotting large time series or other high-density datasets where a full-resolution plot would be too slow, or when there are simply not enough pixels on a screen to display it all. It provides an efficient, simple, and visually accurate representation.
In the context of rocket engine testing and launch operations, LTTB downsampling proves invaluable for real-time monitoring and post-flight analysis of critical engine parameters.
Use Case
In the context of rocket engine testing and launch operations, LTTB downsampling proves invaluable for real-time monitoring and post-flight analysis of critical engine parameters.
Consider a liquid-fueled rocket engine that generates thousands of data points per second across multiple sensors, including:
- Combustion chamber pressure
- Turbopump rotational speed
- Fuel and oxidizer flow rates
- Engine temperature at various points
During a typical 10-minute test firing, this could result in millions of data points. Traditional downsampling methods might miss crucial transient events, such as momentary pressure spikes or sudden temperature fluctuations, which could indicate potential engine instabilities or impending failures.
LTTB enables engineers to:
- Visualize the entire test duration on standard displays without losing critical outliers or trends.
- Quickly identify anomalies like combustion instabilities or turbopump cavitation, which may appear as brief spikes in the data.
- Detect subtle trend changes that might indicate gradual degradation of engine components.
Real-world impact
In one instance, LTTB-based visualization helped identify a 50-millisecond pressure oscillation in the combustion chamber that other downsampling methods had obscured. This anomaly, though brief, indicated a potentially serious issue with the engine's injector plate. Early detection allowed engineers to address the problem before it led to a catastrophic failure.
The cost implications are significant. A single engine test can cost upwards of $1 million, and a launch abort due to engine issues can result in losses exceeding $50 million, not to mention delays to critical missions. By enabling more effective real-time monitoring and post-test analysis, LTTB contributes to:
- Reduced risk of test failures and launch aborts
- More efficient troubleshooting and iteration in engine development
- Improved overall reliability and safety of space launch systems
This use case demonstrates how LTTB's ability to preserve critical data features while efficiently handling large datasets directly translates to tangible benefits in high-stakes aerospace applications.
This use case demonstrates how LTTB's ability to preserve critical data features while efficiently handling large datasets directly translates to tangible benefits in high-stakes aerospace applications.
Gains and Performance Improvements
The implementation of LTTB downsampling in Sift's observability platform has yielded significant gains in both operational efficiency and risk management for hardtech industries, particularly in aerospace applications.
Faster Data Reviews:
By effectively reducing the volume of data while preserving critical features, LTTB enables engineers to conduct faster and more efficient data reviews. What once took hours of sifting through raw telemetry data can now be accomplished in minutes. This rapid analysis capability is particularly crucial in time-sensitive scenarios such as pre-launch checks or post-test evaluations, where quick decision-making can make the difference between a successful mission and a costly delay.
Reduced Delays:
The enhanced visualization provided by LTTB allows for quicker identification of anomalies and potential issues. This rapid detection translates directly into reduced delays in the development and testing phases of aerospace projects. By spotting problems early, teams can address issues proactively, minimizing the need for time-consuming retests or last-minute modifications.
Lower Overall Risk:
With improved data visualization, engineers can more easily identify subtle trends and transient events that might otherwise go unnoticed. This enhanced insight leads to better-informed decisions and more thorough risk assessments. By catching potential issues before they escalate, teams can significantly lower the overall risk profile of their projects, from engine testing to full mission operations.
Improved Collaboration:
LTTB's ability to provide clear, concise visualizations of complex telemetry data coupled with easy collaboration features facilitates better communication between different teams and departments. Engineers, managers, and even non-technical stakeholders can now share a common understanding of system performance and potential issues. This improved collaboration leads to more efficient problem-solving and decision-making processes across the organization.
By leveraging LTTB through Sift's platform, hardtech companies are not just improving their data analysis capabilities; they're fundamentally transforming their approach to system development, testing, and operations. The result is a more agile, informed, and reliable engineering process that is better equipped to meet the challenges of modern aerospace endeavors.
By leveraging LTTB through Sift's platform, hardtech companies are not just improving their data analysis capabilities; they're fundamentally transforming their approach to system development, testing, and operations.
Conclusion
The implementation of the LTTB algorithm in Sift's platform represents a significant advancement in telemetry data visualization for hardtech industries, particularly in aerospace applications. By effectively balancing data reduction with the preservation of critical features, LTTB addresses the fundamental challenges of real-time telemetry analysis in high-stakes environments.
Sift's decision to incorporate LTTB was driven by the need to provide engineers with a robust, efficient solution for visualizing massive telemetry datasets without sacrificing critical insights. The algorithm's O(n) time complexity ensures computational efficiency, making it suitable for real-time processing of high-volume data streams—a key requirement for Sift's users in aerospace.
The integration of LTTB into Sift's platform enhances its ability to deliver actionable insights from complex telemetry data. This efficiency, coupled with LTTB's ability to maintain visual fidelity of key data characteristics, provides engineers using Sift with a powerful tool for rapid anomaly detection and trend analysis, crucial for maintaining safety and performance in aerospace applications.
While LTTB excels in visual representation, Sift recognizes that it may not preserve all statistical properties of the original dataset. Therefore, the platform complements LTTB with additional analytical techniques, offering a comprehensive approach to data interpretation.
Looking ahead, Sift is developing an advanced LTTB implementation for unbounded data streams. This approach creates time-based buckets and applies LTTB to incoming data in real-time, maintaining only two buckets in memory. This significantly reduces memory usage, enables immediate processing of large-scale telemetry, and scales effortlessly with increasing data volumes. Sift is also exploring the integration of machine learning algorithms with this streaming LTTB implementation to enhance anomaly detection capabilities.
As the volume and complexity of telemetry data continue to grow, Sift's implementation of techniques like LTTB plays an increasingly crucial role in enabling engineers to extract actionable insights efficiently. By bridging the gap between raw data and meaningful visualization, Sift's advanced downsampling methods have become indispensable tools for hardtech engineers, contributing to safer, more efficient, and more reliable systems across the aerospace industry and beyond.
Through the strategic application of LTTB and ongoing innovations in data processing, Sift continues to empower engineers with the tools they need to make informed decisions in real-time, ultimately driving the advancement of hardtech industries.
Next Steps
Discuss Sift’s capabilities with our Forward Deployed Engineers? Schedule office hours here.
